Tories demand change to law that will allow soldiers to fight for Britain without ECHR lawfare threat, as they dare Labour MPs to vote against amendment

The Conservative Party will push an amendment to the Armed Forces Bill that would allow the Defence Secretary to ignore the European Convention on Human Rights during times of war.

The major change would give Britain’s servicemen and women peace of mind that they can defend the country without the threat of being dragged through the courts on spurious human rights grounds.

The Tories’ amendment would introduce a duty on the Defence Secretary to consider derogating from the ECHR, under Article 15 of the treaty, before significant overseas military operations.

The convention includes the relevant article because its authors recognised that extraordinary circumstances, such as war, require different legal arrangements.

But increasingly, the ECHR’s overreach is frequently hampering the army’s ability to act effectively and swiftly.

While the Tories’ amendment wouldn’t automatically trigger derogation from the ECHR, it would force ministers to actively consider whether doing so is appropriate before a conflict.

Shadow Secretary of State for Defence, James Cartlidge, told the Mail: ‘Our Armed Forces operate in some of the most dangerous environments on earth.

‘When British troops are deployed on significant overseas operations, Ministers should at the very least be required to consider the circumstances of their operation.

The Tories want to protect British troops from over-zealous human rights legislation in the courts

The amendment would oblige the Defence Secretary to consider displaying the ECHR before any significant overseas military conflict 

‘This amendment introduces a sensible protection against lawfare. We will force a vote to ensure Ministers properly consider derogation from the ECHR where appropriate, helping to protect our personnel from the growing threat of lawfare – allowing them to focus on the mission at hand.

‘Only the Conservatives will take the tough decisions needed to keep Britain safe and stand up for the men and women who serve our country.’

A number of ECHR rulings over the past 15 years have significantly hamstrung British military operations overseas.

In 2011, the European Court of Human Rights made military actions subject to human rights litigation.

That same year, the court ruled that Britain’s detention of a suspected terrorist was unlawful, despite it being authorised by a UN Security Council resolution.

In 2013, the Supreme Court held that Article 2 claims brought by families of soldiers killed in Snatch Land Rovers were arguable, drawing military equipment decisions into human rights litigation.

And the Iraq Historic Allegations Team, which received thousands of allegations against UK soldiers and cost tens of millions of pounds, while securing no prosecutions, was established in part due to ECHR obligations.

Those investigated as part of the IHAT suffered terrible stress, had their lives put on hold, and many had their careers damaged.

The Tories will dare Labour MPs to vote their amendment down, and prove whether they really believe in standing up for Britain’s troops

Keir Starmer’s top legal officer in Cabinet, Lord Hermer, has been accused of pursuing a witch-hunt against troops as a lawyer in 2008

But while many voters will think the Tories’ amendment to be sensible, the party may face an uphill battle protecting soldiers against the current government.

In April, Lord Hermer, the Attorney General, was accused of pursuing a ‘witch hunt’ against British troops when he was a senior lawyer in 2008.

Soldiers who had served their country on the battlefield were hounded with false allegations that they had tortured and murdered civilians after the 2004 Battle of Danny Boy in southern Iraq.

Emails revealed that Lord Hermer was warned that the claims were ‘nonsense’, and even expressed his own doubts.

In one astonishing message to colleague Martyn Day, a leading human rights lawyer, the Attorney General backed moves to publicise the lawsuits during an interview on Radio 4’s Today programme – noting it must leave ‘some wiggle room if the killings did not in fact happen’.

A spokesman for Lord Hermer insisted he was not aware that his clients were telling ‘deliberate lies’ until long afterwards.

A spokesman for the Ministry of Defence said: ‘We remain committed to the European Convention on Human Rights.

‘As the Minister for Armed Forces made clear, the UK cannot opt out of its obligations under the ECHR on a case-by-case basis.

‘Changing domestic law would not remove those obligations.’

Read More

  • Related Posts

    Demand for tunnel maps and personal weapons tests Gaza talks

    Ceasefire talks in Egypt between Palestinian factions and mediators face a serious test after Nickolay Mladenov, the high representative of the “Board of Peace“, demanded that not a “single bullet”…

    Airline CEOs demand Congress restore DHS funding and pay airport workers

    This page either does not exist or is currently unavailable. From here you can either hit the “back” button on your browser to return to the previous page, or visit…

    You Missed

    Andy Burnham urged to rule out naming Ed Miliband as his chancellor by boss of major trade union

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Andy Burnham urged to rule out naming Ed Miliband as his chancellor by boss of major trade union

    Former Olympian is arrested for allegedly vandalizing Reflecting Pool… but he claims he merely touched it

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Former Olympian is arrested for allegedly vandalizing Reflecting Pool… but he claims he merely touched it

    Table for two: Moment thieves are caught on CCTV taking drills to pub to steal outside furniture

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Table for two: Moment thieves are caught on CCTV taking drills to pub to steal outside furniture

    Abuser who repeatedly raped a woman while also pouring hot tea over her gets 16-year term behind bars

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Abuser who repeatedly raped a woman while also pouring hot tea over her gets 16-year term behind bars

    Shirley Henderson says she’d have loved to have starred in classic scene with John Candy

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Shirley Henderson says she’d have loved to have starred in classic scene with John Candy

    Democrat’s mysterious tangled love life: Fake wedding photos… a new fiancée ‘cover up’… and couple’s eyebrow-raising timeline

    • By poster
    • July 22, 2026
    • 1 views
    Democrat’s mysterious tangled love life: Fake wedding photos… a new fiancée ‘cover up’… and couple’s eyebrow-raising timeline