Police finally make arrest after newborn twins were found dumped in rat-infested alley in New York City

By SAMANTHA RUTT, US TRAINEE REPORTER

Published: | Updated:

A Bronx mother accused of dumping her newborn twins in a rat-infested alley in New York City has been arrested, five years after the heinous crime.

Stephanie Castillo, 36, was taken into custody Friday morning and charged with multiple counts of murder and manslaughter in connection with the deaths of her infant sons, law enforcement sources confirmed.

The arrest follows a years-long investigation that recently linked Castillo to the crime through DNA evidence. She kept her head low during her perp walk.

On November 9, 2020, the babies were discovered in a filthy alley behind a College Avenue apartment building, near East 171st Street, in the Claremont section of the Bronx.

One of the newborn babies was partially wrapped in a pet training pad with visible head trauma and an umbilical cord tied around his neck. The other was found about 20 feet away, tucked inside a black plastic bag.

Both were less than 24 hours old and had been born alive, according to police.

Castillo was arrested at a nearby shelter, just blocks from the apartment where she had previously lived – and from which police believe she may have thrown the babies out a fourth-floor window.

Stephanie Castillo, 36, was taken into custody Friday morning and charged with multiple counts of murder and manslaughter in connection with the deaths of her infant sons

On November 9, 2020, the babies were discovered in a filthy alley behind a College Avenue apartment building, near East 171st Street, in the Claremont section of the Bronx (pictured)

The NYPD Crime Scene Unit walked out of the fourth floor apartment carrying evidence bags following Castillo’s arrest (pictured) 

‘The perpetrator in this case resided on the fourth floor of this apartment building, and we believe that the babies were disposed of out the window,’ NYPD Assistant Chief Michael Baldassano told CBS New York.

The twins, later named Zeke and Zane by detectives, were buried after officers raised money for their funeral.

The case remained unsolved for years despite a $10,000 reward and repeated public pleas, according The New York Times.

Castillo is now charged with two counts of murder and manslaughter. She is being held at the 44th Precinct and is expected to be arraigned in Bronx Criminal Court.

According to sources speaking to the NYPost, the mother unknowingly nailed herself to the crime after DNA was taken from a drink container she used – matching the genetics of the suspected baby killer.   

Castillo is now charged with two counts of murder and manslaughter. She is being held at the 44th Precinct and is expected to be arraigned in Bronx Criminal Court (pictured: NYPD Crime Scene Unit carrying out evidence bags)

The arrest follows a years-long investigation that recently linked Castillo to the crime through DNA evidence

The case dates back to 2020 when the building superintendent made the disturbing discovery behind the College Avenue property (pictured)

‘This is exactly why we come to work every day. The NYPD, we don’t give up. Our detectives are the best in the world,’ Baldassano said. 

The case dates back to 2020 when the building superintendent made the disturbing discovery behind the College Avenue property.

The city’s medical examiner later ruled the deaths homicides in April 2021, citing blunt force trauma to the head and torso as the cause.

In the years since the incident, members of the NYPD and local community have held annual vigils in memory of the boys, who were given a proper funeral after officers and detectives pooled donations to pay for burial services.

Read More

  • Related Posts

    Police watchdog to investigate motorway crash that killed two men: Patrol car had activated its blue lights after spotting car driving in wrong direction

    Get your news delivered straight to you by 7am – sign up to our new Morning Mail newsletter for FREE By TOM LAWRENCE, NEWS REPORTER Published: 15:37 EDT, 19 April…

    As Erika Kirk FINALLY comes out of hiding at State of the Union, shock new exposé plagues ‘giggling’ widow… who can’t shake questions over her tears and THOSE leather pants

    Erika Kirk, the country’s most famous widow, may have new cause for tears after she appeared as a special guest at Tuesday’s State of the Union address. President Donald Trump invited…

    You Missed

    Anthony Albanese to deliver address to the nation TONIGHT as he makes urgent plea to all Australians: ‘Play their part’

    • By poster
    • May 24, 2026
    • 2 views
    Anthony Albanese to deliver address to the nation TONIGHT as he makes urgent plea to all Australians: ‘Play their part’

    Labour could lose ‘well over’ 1,000 councillors -elections continues, say top pollsters

    • By poster
    • May 24, 2026
    • 2 views
    Labour could lose ‘well over’ 1,000 councillors -elections continues, say top pollsters

    President Trump announces an ‘Address to the Nation’ on Iran

    • By poster
    • May 24, 2026
    • 2 views
    President Trump announces an ‘Address to the Nation’ on Iran

    The fatal hospital blunder that cost young tradie, 22, his life

    • By poster
    • May 24, 2026
    • 2 views
    The fatal hospital blunder that cost young tradie, 22, his life

    Sacked BBC star Scott Mills admitted pinning an ex-boyfriend to the wall by his throat after he betrayed him and found him in bed with his friend

    • By poster
    • May 24, 2026
    • 2 views
    Sacked BBC star Scott Mills admitted pinning an ex-boyfriend to the wall by his throat after he betrayed him and found him in bed with his friend

    World’s oldest known tortoise dies aged 193: Jonathan

    • By admin
    • May 23, 2026
    • 2 views
    World’s oldest known tortoise dies aged 193: Jonathan