
Furious locals have objected to controversial plans for a traveller pitch on land that was used as an orphanage during World War Two.
John and Cindy Ayres have applied to put a mobile home on the historic site near Henley-on-Thames in Oxfordshire – despite their plans being rejected once before.
Villagers have branded the proposals ‘unsuitable’, ‘inappropriate’ and raised concerns about the site’s ‘proximity to a local nursery and playing fields’.
The area in Sonning Common is part of a former Second World War camp, and is also located in an area of outstanding natural beauty.
More than 300 orphans were moved to the site from a London orphanage during the Blitz, with two deteriorating buildings still remaining.
Mr and Ms Ayres applied to build two traveller pitches on the land next to Bishopswood recreation ground in 2022, but this was rejected on appeal in January last year.
However, their second bid comes as new planning policy announced by Angela Rayner will force councils to release green belt land to travellers if there is an ‘unmet need’ for pitches.
At present neither temporary or permanent travellers’ sites are allowed on green belt land as they fail to qualify as ‘very special circumstances’ – but that is about to change.
John and Cindy Ayres have applied to put a mobile home on the historic site in Sonning Common, Oxfordshire – despite their plans being rejected once before (picture shows site)
Angela Rayner introduced new planning proposals that will compel local councils to house travellers on greenbelt land if they fail to provide nomadic communities with sufficient land
The area, next to Bishopwood recreation ground, is part of a former Second World War camp and is also located in an area of outstanding natural beauty
A consultation, published in December, stated that proposals should no longer be considered as inappropriate if there is an ‘unmet need for the type of development’.
Mr and Ms Ayres have made clear in their application to South Oxfordshire District Council their plans address a shortage of traveller sites in the county.
There are currently only ten traveller sites in south Oxfordshire – a shortfall of 34 pitches, the Henley Standard has reported.
However more than 20 locals have already objected to the ‘inappropriate’ plans in Sonning Common, which are also located close to a public footpath.
David Phillips wrote on the public planning portal: ‘I raise an objection to the application on several grounds.
‘The application has been rejected twice previously and also on appeal. Nothing has changed. The proposal is out of settlement and inappropriate given adjacency to nursery school and playing fields.
‘The development would hinder the free usage of the public right of way running through the site.’
Local Jonathon Edney added: ‘The heavy toll the proposed development will have on both the children’s nursery and the nearby playing fields is in my opinion too heavy a cost to bear.
More than 20 locals have already objected to the ‘inappropriate’ plans, which are also located close to a public footpath (picture shows the site)
An aerial view of the site off Gallowstree Road in Sonning Common, Oxfordshire
Mr and Ms Ayres applied by build two traveller pitches on the land in 2022 but this was rejected on appeal in January last year
‘The physical and mental health benefits of exercise are well documented, as is the way that open playing space for our young people’s recreational pursuits has been eroded in recent years.
‘I would therefore urge you not to put the wellbeing of our local youngsters at risk by approving this application.’
Little Beeches Nursery which is located close to the development site also objected to the plans.
The owners raised concerns about the impact on the ‘character of the landscape’, the effect on ‘biodiversity’ and the effect on trees in the area.
However, Mr and Ms Ayres said the traveller site will not ‘negatively impact’ the site and added that it would be ‘sensitively designed’.
They are also proposing to enclose the pitch with native hedgerows and reinforce the existing boundary shrubs.
It comes as a traveller was told in September last year he could continue living in a mobile home in a field in nearby Goring-on-Thames, despite the objections of dozens of residents and the local council.
Nelson Rogers, 37, successfully appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after he installed, without planning permission, a static caravan and septic tank on land opposite the village cemetery in September 2022.
Two months later, South Oxfordshire District Council issued him an enforcement notice demanding the work be undone within four months.
Pictured: A mobile home in a field in Goring-on-Thames, Oxfordshire, that was approved as a traveller site following an appeal
Pictured: Building work being undertaken at the entrance to a traveller site in Goring-on-Thames, Oxfordshire
A general view of the mobile home in a field in Goring-on-Thames that was set up opposite the village’s cemetery
However, Mr Rogers, appealed, resulting in an inquiry that was heard by planning inspector Thomas Shields in April last year.
He argued that he should be granted permission for the mobile home as the district council did not have a five-year supply of traveller pitches.
The appeal was granted, despite concerns being raised by dozens of local residents that the development was situated in an area of outstanding natural beauty.
One local wrote on the public planning portal: ‘The adjacent burial ground is a place for quiet reflection and grieving when needed and any building would disrupt this.
‘There should be no change of use and no development on this site and the mobile home which is currently there should be removed.’
Another added: ‘This is one of the very few areas of outstanding beauty which we must preserve for future generations to experience the peace, tranquility and solemnity, and to escape the pressures of our ever increasing hectic lives.
‘The noise created by such a development – with a loud generator running day and night – would be disturbing and intimidating to people at their most vulnerable time and during funerals taking place.’
How is Labour targeting the green belt?
Labour has vowed to build 1.5million new homes over its first five years in power, which it hopes to achieve by overhauling planning laws.
Deputy PM Angela Rayner is overseeing the promised building blitz.
Her Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) has unveiled major changes to previous green belt protections.
What is the green belt?
There are around 6,300 square miles of green belt land in England, covering around 12.5 per cent of England’s land area.
It is designed to prevent urban sprawl into the countryside and is clustered around 15 urban areas.
Supporters of the green belt say it provides recreational opportunities and contact with nature close to where people live.
But others see it as a block on much-needed development.
What is ‘grey belt’ land?
Under an updated National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) – unveiled by Labour in December – local councils are being ordered to review their current green belt boundaries.
This is with the aim of identifying lower-quality land – such as disused petrol stations and car parks – that could be built on and rebranded as ‘grey belt’.
What about traveller sites?
Labour’s shake-up of planning rules has made clear that ‘demonstrable unmet need’ for traveller sites can justify the release of green belt land for the development of new sites.
What else is Labour changing?
The Government has also moved to reduce key green belt protections for villages.
New MHCLG guidance has stated that villages ‘should not be considered large built up areas’ for the purpose of checking the ‘unrestricted sprawl’ of development.
Another aim of the green belt is to ‘preserve the setting and special character of historic towns’.
But the new MHCLG advice made clear that this purpose ‘relates to historic towns, not villages’.
Ms Rayner has also set out moves to slash the number of official bodies that can object to new developments.
In December, Housing Secretary Angela Rayner announced a major planning overhaul as part of plans to build 1.5 million homes in the next five years
There are around 6,300 square miles of green belt land in England, which is designed to prevent urban sprawl into the countryside (Stock image)